CBD oil and seizures. Oh, and please stop pitting “Science” against “Nature.”

Last week, a New Zealand current matters of state program, 3D (3rd Degree), opened their programming by a segment about a recent “groundbreaking” capsule – watch it here. Over the past several months, the country heard the heartbreaking record of a young man, Alex Renton, endurance from continuous seizures and placed in a stupor in an attempt to essentially obstacle his brain rest. People really started vigilance when his family requested that he have existence treated with CBD (cannabidiol) oil, a unite obtained from marijuana. Alex became the pristine person in New Zealand to have existence treated with CBD oil within a hospital. Unfortunately on the side of the Renton family, the CBD oil was unavailing.

Perhaps the segment on 3D was foolishly meant to be a piece relative to the family, about Alex’s novel. It would have been really fantastic to know some scientific information in that section though. There is research out in that place about medical marijuana, and I personally be wrought up a little bit of scientific commentary would get improved that segment immensely. Here are more of my thoughts.

Is there evidence that CBD could be helpful in this case? I’m going to say, not indeed. Alex’s seizures were apparently kindred to encephalitis, which means that his brain was inflamed. I was good to find one recent, small notice critically of research investigating marijuana’s goods on various types of inflammation in beast of the field models. While some of the results soundly promising, human trials are yet to occur. Perhaps the possible promise of CBD in this put in a box came from many positive stories in cases of falling sickness, which is a chronic seizure impair the functions of, of which there are various various kinds.

It’s important to record here, CBD is different from THC (Tetrahydrocannabinol) that is the psychoactive compound in marijuana – the effects that gets people high. Each of these cannabinoids (in ~ degree of the compounds found in marijuana) be able to have different actions and different personal estate. In the case of epilepsy studies, THC has had joined results for treating seizures. In more cases, it reduces seizures, but in others it promotes them. However, CBD has been consistently anticonvulsant (it reduces seizures).

Although randomised controlled trials as far as concerns treatment of epilepsy with CBD are lacking, there is a long history of marijuana’s practice to the treatment of epilepsy. Reports of a resolution in seizures date back to the 19th century. There are also multiple case reports by dramatic reductions in seizures, at in the smallest degree one report of an increase in seizures subsequent to patients stopped marijuana, and animal models indicating CBD reduces taking activity. For different epilepsy conditions, CBD seems to have existence likely effective, at least in reducing gripe frequency. Unfortunately, Alex Renton did not own epilepsy, and this difference may exist crucial in whether or not cannabis based medicines are effective.

I say this because there is manifest that the endocannabinoid system is involved in the creation of seizures in epilepsy models. The endocannabinoid universe refers to receptors found throughout the central vigorous system where the compounds in marijuana act. This scheme exists for messengers that are in the limits of our brains naturally, but compounds institute within marijuana are very similar to these naturally occurring molecules. This connected view seems to be involved in more way with seizure activity, although in what way this happens exactly is unclear and that may be liked complex. But, to quote directly from Szaflarski & Bebin (for the reason that it’s better than I could tell it):

“The current data not solitary support the role of the [endocannabinoid plan] in the generation and maintenance of seizures moreover also explain the positive effects of THC in successi~ seizure control in animal models of falling sickness. Further, the data support the universal idea that CBD is an effective and potentially cogent anticonvulsant in animal models of epilepsy and that, through synergism with THC, it may set to work. direct and indirect effects on catching control. Whether these or other personal estate will be observed in human falling sickness remains to be seen, but the results of sentient being studies appear to be in agreement by some of the anecdotal human facts.”

This situation was not person of epilepsy. In applying scientific findings, the context matters – if you change the context, results don’t necessarily generalise.

I also thought this segment was a little bit sensationalist. Whether it was conferred intentionally or not, marijuana in this part seemed to be associated with alternative remedies such as homeopathy. At any point they even say “Alex responded to no part, pharmaceutical or alternative.” In ~-ending you know absolutely nothing about homeopathic “remedies,” they are essentially ~y over-hyped placebo. A placebo is a portion that all drugs are tested in compensation for, which is essentially a sugar pill. [Aside: suppose that you’re interested in placebos, I commit this great Derren Brown show, Fear and Faith.] Homeopathy works not at all better than a placebo. Marijuana, on the other hand, even with the indigence for further research, can work better than a placebo for things like squeamishness and vomiting associated with chemotherapy, or against controlling certain aspects of Multiple Sclerosis, or in the same manner with above in controlling seizures (among other things). It’s not a enchantment bullet, it’s not a blanket handling for everything that ails you, further as the research progresses, marijuana is differentiating itself from alternative therapies.

Additionally, it seemed to pit the beliefs of Rose Renton in equalization of medical science. At several points she vehemently disagrees by things that Alex’s doctors uttered, seemingly because of her strong hopes placed in the CBD oil. In a recital to 3D, Alex’s doctors maxim the CBD oil could have interacted with the drugs he was being given. I was skilful to find one study (that was very old, but don’t hold that in anticipation of it!) indicating that CBD reduces the effectiveness of distinct anti-seizure drugs (chlordiazepoxide, clonazepam, trimethadione and ethosuximide) in some animal model. If that finding generalises to humans, and whether or not Alex was on any of those drugs, the CBD may indeed consider interfered in their effectiveness.

Aside from that scientific aspect though, do we really be in want of to promote this narrative of “natural” against “scientific?” It starts sounding like the anti-GMO, anti-vax, anti-pharma conversations: Your knowledge is wrong and we know improvement. The scientific research is restricted in conditions of CBD and seizures, and those practicing body of knowledge-based medicine would of course have existence reluctant to generalise from it broadly. Pitting “activists” to match scientists doesn’t work out on this account that anyone – the general public enjoin think those advocating for medical marijuana are crackpots, and scientists and doctors enjoin be less willing to work by the medical marijuana movement. And therefore, what about those scientists who accept looked into the research, who are of the opinion that marijuana could be a viable medicament? Will the general public then give credit to the science, see the nuance we try to bring to the conversation? Or do you count they’ll lump us in by the crackpots?

Let’s put it out there: Marijuana and associated compounds are not “enchantment bullets.” There is some promising research that in a small account of conditions, marijuana or components of it be able to provide an effective treatment. There likewise exists, early stage research investigating marijuana compounds in sundry animal models of disease. Claims of the healing value of marijuana can be easily overblown, only this doesn’t mean it doesn’t clinch promise. It just means more examination is needed for more conditions. Please remember, that is where the scientific research broadly stands put ~ this issue. Every paper I’ve understand this weekend is in relation to individual condition – epilepsy. Every paper says that there is more research needed. How determination we ever get to the attribute where more research exists, if mob are likely to view medical marijuana like just another alternative therapy? How are we going to be able to make medical marijuana serviceable in those conditions where it is operative, and improve at least the character of life for many ill persons, if scientists and activists can’t labor together?

Devinsky, O, Cilio, MR, Cross, H, Fernandez-Ruiz, J, French, J, Hill, C et al. (2014). Cannabidiol: Pharmacology and potential therapeutic role in epilepsy and other neuropsychiatric disorders. Epilepsia, 55(6), pp791-802.
Gordon, E & Devinsky, O. (2001). Alcohol and Marijuana: Effects put ~ epilepsy and use by patients by epilepsy. Epilepsia, 42(10), pp1266-1272.
Maa, E, & Figi, P. (2014). The box for medical marijuana in epilepsy. Epilepsia, 55(6), pp783-786.
Hegde, M, Santos-Sanchez, C, Hess, CP, Kabir, AA, Garcia, PA. (2012). Seizure heightening in two patients with focal epilepsy following marijuana cessation. Epilepsy and Behavior, 25(4), pp563-566.
Consroe, P, & Wolkin, A. (1977). Cannabidiol-antiepileptic medicine comparisons and interactions in experimentally induced seizures in rats. The Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics, 201, pp26-32.
Szaflarski, JP, & Bebin, EM. (2014). Cannabis, cannabidiol, and falling sickness – from receptors to clinical rejoinder. Epilepsy and Behavior, 41, pp277-282.
Jones, NA, Glyn, SE, Akiyama, S, Hill, TDM, Hill, AJ, Weston, SE et al. (2012). Cannabidiol exerts anti-convulsant furniture in animal models of temporal lobe and imperfect seizures. Seizure, 21(5), pp344-352.
Consroe, P, Benedito, MAC, Leite, JR, Carlini, EA & Mechoulam, R. (1982). Effects of cannabidiol adhering behavioral seizures caused by convulsant drugs or current in mice. European Journal of Pharmacology, 83(3-4), pp293-298.
Karler, R, & Turkanis, SA. (2013). The cannabinoids to the degree that potential antiepileptics. The Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 21(S1), pp437S-448S.
Burstein, S. (2015). Cannabidiol and its analogs: A pass in ~ of their effects on inflammation. Bioorganic and Medicinal Chemistry, 23(7), pp1377-1385.
Porter, BE, & Jacobson, C. (2013). Report of a parent survey of cannabidiol-enriched cannabis conversion to an act in pediatric treatment-resistant epilepsy. Epilepsy and Behavior, 29(3), pp574-577.

I’d subsist less aware of the rose gardens I walk by to get to the kids’ seminary (but also less hyper about the bees up~ the body the buds).

Both comments and pings are currently closed.